Practice Areas
Ashwini Mate, counsel at The Freedman Firm, is a veteran criminal appellate attorney who served for over a decade at the Federal Public Defender’s Office. She focuses on criminal defense in both the California and federal appellate courts. Having argued more than 50 cases in front of appellate courts, Ashwini is a seasoned and highly effective appellate advocate who brings a mastery of complex records, sharp issue-spotting, and persuasive written and oral advocacy. She also draws upon these skills in developing creative legal arguments and powerful motions in support of the firm’s work in the trial courts.
Ashwini serves as a panel attorney on several indigent defense appellate panels across California and the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Her work includes post-conviction motions, including Racial Justice Act (RJA) petitions filed under California’s landmark law that prohibits racial bias in criminal convictions and sentencing.
She also has experience representing individuals who are fighting against conservatorships based on mental health disorders under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, a California law designed to regulate involuntary civil commitments to mental health institutions.
Appellate Court Successes
Ashwini has successfully represented clients in numerous criminal appeals. Her work has resulted in precedent-setting published appellate court opinions, including:
- A published en banc (full court) ruling in United States v. Anderson from the Ninth Circuit in 2024 that reversed a lower court’s denial of a motion to suppress a firearm found during a warrantless search of the defendant’s vehicle. This is considered a significant ruling because it found that an incomplete inventory of items discovered during the search violated the Constitution because law enforcement failed to follow standard procedures, thereby invalidating the evidence they found.
- A published opinion in People v. Kinnear, in which the California Court of Appeal rejected the sentence for a criminal threats conviction, finding in 2025 that the lower court erred by not advising the defendant of his right to a jury trial on an alleged prior conviction.
- A published opinion in United States v. Shetler, in which the Ninth Circuit in 2011 granted an acquittal to Ashwini’s client on charges related to maintaining a drug-involved premises. The court found there was insufficient evidence to infer that the property was primarily used for manufacturing, distributing, or using methamphetamine, as required by the statute. She has also filed, and won, compassionate release motions and a clemency petition.
In addition, she has won unpublished decisions in direct appeals and habeas petitions, including but not limited to:
- Phillip L. Wright v. Connie Gibson: The Ninth Circuit found the prosecutor in the sanity phase of a California State Court criminal trial violated the defendant’s due process by arguing that the defendant’s invoking his post-Miranda right to silence and counsel was sufficient evidence to reject the insanity plea.
- United States v. Valentin: A United States District Court found on appeal that a magistrate judge erred by finding a defendant guilty of driving under the influence on federal property. The prosecution did not adequately prove federal jurisdiction over the state crime because it did not prove that the exact location where the alleged crime took place was within the boundaries of a federal naval base.
- United States v. Carrillo: The Ninth Circuit reversed the conviction for a man accused of breaking into a federal building, finding prosecutors misled the jury on the law.
- Dubrin v. Davey: The Untied States District Court for the Central District of California granted a petition for writ of habeas corpus brought by a defendant on breach of contract claims against state prosecutors over a plea agreement.
- United States v. Ogburn: The Ninth Circuit reversed a lower court’s denial of downward sentencing adjustment for failure to register as a sex offender.
- United States v. Rogelio Ruiz Alonso: The Ninth Circuit vacated a plea and sentence for a defendant convicted of illegal reentry and violation of supervised release, finding the lower court failed to follow Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11 procedures, especially concerning his plea agreement.
- Successfully negotiated several remands with the government.
Appellate Defense Experience
Prior to joining The Freedman Firm, Ashwini served for over a decade as an appellate defender at the Federal Public Defender’s Office, where she briefed and argued numerous appeals and non-capital habeas petitions in the Central District of California and the Ninth Circuit.
While attending the University of California, Los Angeles School of Law, she externed for the Hon. Audrey B. Collins in the Central District of California (now sitting on the California Court of Appeal Court), worked at the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights in the San Francisco Bay Area, and interned at the Los Angeles County Public Defender’s Office. After law school, she continued to work for the Los Angeles County Public Defender’s office until obtaining her post at the Federal Public Defender’s Office.
Education
- University of California, Los Angeles School of Law, J.D.
- Wesleyan University, B.A.
Bar & Court Admissions
- California
- Guam
- United States District Court for the Central and Eastern Districts of California
- United States District Court for the District of Nevada
- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
- California Court of Appeal
- United States Supreme Court
More of our team
-
Michael G. Freedman
Managing Partner
-
Carolyn Holloway
Legal Assistant & Office Manager
-
Jonathan Umanzor
Associate
-
Dawn Saucier-Green
Paralegal





